DraftKings DFS MLB All-Star Game Strategy & Picks
DraftKings released DFS picks and strategy for the 2026 MLB All-Star Game, highlighting top Captain and UTIL plays, as well as players to fade due to pitching matchups.
Written by the Fantasy Tutor editorial pipeline from 1 primary source. How we source →
The 2026 MLB All-Star Game offers a unique DFS Showdown slate on DraftKings. Despite the event's limited plate appearances for hitters, strategic player selection can lead to winning lineups. The challenge involves identifying high-floor players and leveraging matchup advantages against the opposing league's pitching staff Source.
Captain Pick: Yordan Alvarez
Yordan Alvarez ($10,000) is identified as a top Captain play despite his high salary. His incredibly high floor balances the cost, especially since value options are available elsewhere in the contest. Alvarez enters the Midsummer Classic with 100th percentile marks in expected batting average (.335), expected slugging (.713), and expected wOBA (.474).
He faces a left-on-left matchup against Cristopher Sanchez ($6,000) in the first inning. However, this is not a concern, as Alvarez boasts a .458 expected wOBA specifically against left-handed pitchers, the highest in MLB. This makes him an elite option for the Captain's slot, where points are multiplied.
Utility (UTIL) Picks
Shea Langeliers
Shea Langeliers ($7,400) is highlighted for his ability to hit left-handed pitching. He slashes .324/.388/.629 with a 177 wRC+ against southpaws, and his .571 expected slugging percentage against lefties is the seventh-highest qualified mark in the league. Langeliers is projected to bat third in the AL lineup and will face Sanchez in his first at-bat. The National League's starting pitching rotation is notably left-handed heavy, increasing his chances for favorable matchups.
Max Muncy
Max Muncy ($4,800) presents significant value. He is one of the cheapest starters available, with only Ernie Clement ($3,200) priced lower. Muncy, batting fifth in the NL lineup, is likely to avoid facing Dylan Cease ($5,600), who has the league's second-best FIP (2.19) and lowest opponent home runs per nine (0.46). This lineup spot could allow Muncy to get at-bats against the AL's secondary pitchers, such as Nick Martinez ($4,200) and Michael Wacha ($4,200).
Jhoan Duran
Selecting a relief pitcher in a Showdown format is typically high-risk, but Jhoan Duran ($4,000) is an exception. Given his impressive 1.38 ERA and 1.08 FIP across 32.2 innings this season, and his 100th percentile strikeout rate (39.7%), he offers a high ceiling in a single inning. The potential for multiple strikeouts in his appearance could significantly boost DFS scores.
Players to Fade
Miguel Vargas
Miguel Vargas ($7,200) is identified as a fade candidate. While not a direct criticism of Vargas's individual performance, he is the most expensive bench bat for the AL, which is generally an archetype to avoid in this format. The National League's pitching depth is noted as superior, even without key arms like Jacob Misiorowski, Paul Skenes, and Chase Burns. The NL boasts strong relievers such as Yoshinobu Yamamoto ($5,200), Chris Sale ($5,200), and Jesus Luzardo ($4,600), suggesting less favorable matchups for AL reserves compared to NL reserves.
Key takeaways
- 01Yordan Alvarez is a high-floor Captain pick, despite his salary, due to elite expected stats and strong performance vs. left-handers.
- 02Shea Langeliers offers strong value as a UTIL pick, specifically targeting left-handed pitching, which is prevalent in the NL's starters.
- 03Max Muncy is an undervalued UTIL play, positioned to face the AL's weaker relief pitching and offering significant pop.
- 04Jhoan Duran is a high-upside, high-risk reliever pick for UTIL due to his elite strikeout rate, even in a single inning.
- 05Avoid Miguel Vargas and other expensive AL bench bats due to the superior depth of the NL pitching staff.
Frequently asked
What is the recommended Captain's pick for the All-Star Game DraftKings Showdown?+
Yordan Alvarez is recommended as the Captain's pick due to his high floor, strong expected stats, and elite performance against left-handed pitchers, despite his high salary.
Which utility players offer the best value or upside for DFS lineups?+
Shea Langeliers is a strong UTIL pick for his performance against left-handed pitchers. Max Muncy offers value due to his low cost and favorable matchup potential against secondary AL pitchers. Jhoan Duran is a high-upside, high-risk reliever pick for his strikeout ability.
Are there any players to avoid in the DraftKings Showdown contest?+
Miguel Vargas and other expensive American League bench bats are suggested fades. This is due to the perceived superior depth of the National League's pitching staff, creating difficult matchups for AL reserves.
How should player salaries factor into All-Star Game DFS strategy?+
While players like Yordan Alvarez have high salaries, the availability of strong value options elsewhere in the Showdown contest means salary constraints are less of a concern. Focus on high-floor players and favorable matchups.
What is the significance of pitcher matchups in the All-Star Game DFS?+
Pitcher matchups are crucial, especially with limited plate appearances. Targeting hitters with strong splits against specific handedness (e.g., Langeliers vs. LHPs) or who are likely to avoid elite starting pitching (e.g., Muncy avoiding Cease) is key.
Sources
Every briefing is drafted from primary sources - official announcements, vendor blogs, and reputable industry reporting - then edited by our pipeline.
More on DFS Strategy
See all →Free account
Want to go deeper?
Sign up free to unlock the full daily industry feed, save posts and articles to your library, and chat with the AI tutor about anything you read.